“The Disciple” Returns India to Venice Film Fest Competition

September 3, 2020

SEOUL, South Korea — A film about a classical musician's struggle to balance his career dreams and life in contemporary Mumbai will this week return India to the main competition at the Venice Film Festival for the first time in nearly two decades.

Writer-director Chaitanya Tamhane's "The Disciple" is among the 18-films selected for competition at the festival, which opened Wednesday. The last Indian film in competition was "Monsoon Wedding" by Mira Nair, which in 2001 won the festival's top prize, the Golden Lion.

Tamhane spent four years researching, filming and editing "The Disciple," which follows a would-be classical music vocalist who struggles to balance his craft's centuries-old traditions with contemporary Mumbai.

His film is slated to premiere Friday and despite travel restrictions and precautions due to the coronavirus pandemic, Tamhane plans to be there.

"It's been my dream, in a way to, you know, (to) be in competition at the festival," he said. "You know, there would be no bigger high than presenting the film in person at Venice."

"I started off almost like a journalist, you know, attending concerts, interviewing musicians and hanging out in these spaces that they inhabit. So it took me two years to do the research, travel around the country and write the script," Tamhane, 33, said in an interview last month.

"Indian classical musicians — there is a general perception that they are very serious and, you know, and they are very sort of solemn and somber. And once you start hanging out with them, once you start kind of talking to them, you realize that they're just as normal, as ordinary as all of us," he said. "And they're also in their respective field facing the same kind of issues, the same kind of problems that, you know, a journalist would be facing or an athlete would be facing."

"It was a process for me to arrive at that realization," he said.

As with his 2014 debut feature, "Court," which takes a swipe at the Indian legal system through the trial of an aging folk singer, "The Disciple" reflects his concerns about society.

"'Court' was a lot more observational, a lot more objective. 'The Disciple', I would say, is a lot more subjective," he said. "A lot of my observations about society and people, you know, do kind of seep into the script. And I feel not just me, everybody should be socially conscious and not be insular and live in a bubble, and react and engage with what's happening around us."

"Court" won Best Film in the Orizzonti section that runs parallel to the main Venice Film Festival competition. It also won Tamhane the Lion of the Future award given to best first films.

Tamhane said he can relate to people swimming against the tide. 

"I kind of think that I am on the fringe, you know, of the mainstream film industry in India, which is so dominant," he said. 

At 19, he took a jab at his homeland's film industry with his documentary "Four Step Plan," which addressed plagiarism in Indian films.

"So when something is so popular, so dominant as an entire machinery, how do you survive? How do you find your own voice? How do you do something that's not going to have, say, as big an audience and never going to make as much money or gain as much popularity? So then how do you keep going? How do you find your audience," he said. 

Those themes also run through "The Disciple." Tamhane said he doesn't take for granted that he'll be able to continue to make movies.

"I may not get to make the kind of things that I want to make is a constant fear in my mind," he said. "Even when I was shooting this film every single day, I would remind myself that, you know, I've been blessed, I'm privileged that I'm getting to do this. And this might not be the case in a few years."


CANNES, France (AP) — The verdict is in: The titular “Dog on Trial” was declared this year's Palm Dog winner in Cannes on Friday.

Top Stories


A pregnant woman was driving in the HOV lane near Dallas.

General News

NEW YORK – Meropi Kyriacou, the new Principal of The Cathedral School in Manhattan, was honored as The National Herald’s Educator of the Year.


2 Germans, a Spaniard and a Senegalese Killed in Building Collapse in Spain’s Mallorca Island

MADRID (AP) — Spain's National Police on Friday gave details on four people killed when a building housing a bar and restaurant club collapsed on the island of Mallorca.

THRU JUNE 4 NEW YORK – The third iteration of the Carte Blanche project featuring Maria Antelman with the work ‘The Seer (Deep)’ opened on April 19 and runs through June 4, Monday-Friday 9 AM-2:30 PM, at the Consulate General of Greece in New York, 69 East 79th Street in Manhattan.

ATHENS – An Archieratical Divine Liturgy and a memorial service honoring the 50th dark anniversary of the Turkish invasion of Cyprus at the Metropolis – the Greek Orthodox Cathedral of Athens – marked the beginning of the 4th Archon International Conference on Religious Freedom of the Archons of the Ecumenical Patriarchate on Sunday, May 26.

NEW YORK – Greek-American Republican congresswoman Nicole Malliotakis gave a strong and clear response to reports by American media such as The Hill and Politico regarding the purpose of her presence at the trial in the well-known ‘hush money’ case against former President Donald Trump.

NIKOSIA - Dust and other potentially toxic emissions are being caused by renovations at the Makarios Children’s Hospital in Nicosia which specializes in treating cancer cases, charities helping there have complained.

Enter your email address to subscribe

Provide your email address to subscribe. For e.g. [email protected]

You may unsubscribe at any time using the link in our newsletter.