x

Columnists

Historical Observations: An Indian Muslim View of Constantinople in 1919

October 11, 2020

The leading Indian Muslim, Agha Khan 111 (Sir Sultan Mohammed Shah, 1877-1957) held the title of prince which was recognized by the British government. As the leading Muslim leader in India, he commanded a lot of power and respect amongst his people and co-religionists. He used his prominent position to advance Muslim interests and that of the Ottoman Empire during the Paris peace conference in 1919.

During the early stages of the conference, the allied powers had to decide on the future of Constantinople and whether the Sultan's government would remain there or be banished to Asia Minor. The Indian Muslims used this period to campaign for Constantinople to remain the seat of the Ottoman Empire. At this time, Great Britain was the world's leading Muslim power where Indian Muslim agitation could cause her problems in Egypt, Mesopotamia (Iraq), Arabia, and Palestine.

The Agha Khan along with other leading Indian Muslims Ameer Ali, Sir Abbas Ali Baig, and Yusuf Ali signed a memorial which was handed to the British Foreign Secretary, Arthur J. Balfour in Paris regarding the future of Constantinople. The memorial was couched in moderate language to persuade the British delegation to understand Indian Muslim feelings as to what Constantinople meant to them.

The Agha Khan stated that he spoke for 80 million Muslim subjects in India who were loyal to the British Empire during the great war. They contributed money and troops to the Indian army who played a very important role in the British Empire's victories in Europe and the Middle East. A prominent Indian Muslim, Nazim of Hyderabad contributed one million pounds towards the British war effort and also kept the Muslim population pacified under his authority.

Indian Muslims remained loyal to the British government which they lived under, but prayed for their Caliph, who was the Sultan of Turkey. Whilst they helped the British war effort, their prayers in the mosques of India were for the Sultan. The Agha Khan mentioned that this devotion for the Sultan was of recent origin without specifying a specific date. However, it was a remarkable fact that the British government shouldn't ignore or underestimate the loyalty of Indian Muslims towards the Sultan.

The memorial declared that Indian Muslim loyalty had been tested with calmness when Turkey had been defeated in the Balkan Wars of 1912-13. There was no civil unrest during that time and even when Constantinople was to be handed over to Russia. It was important for the British government to pay attention to the law-abiding Indian Muslims "who have withstood temptation, and notwithstanding their sympathies, loyally and enthusiastically supported the Allied cause."

It was important that any attempt by Britain to deprive Turkey of its capital, Constantinople would raise the specter of rebellion among Indian Muslims and create problems for the British in India. Indian Muslims wanted to maintain good relations with the Indian government.

They quoted the British Prime Minister Lloyd George’s war aims speech of January 5, 1918, to support their case. He said, "we are not fighting to deprive Turkey of its capital" which was a great relief felt among the Muslim population. Nazim set the example celebrating the allied victory and the collapse of their enemies by offering thanksgiving prayers in his mosque. The end of hostilities meant that peace between the Turks and the British was now restored.

However, they failed to mention in their memorial that Arabia, Armenia, Mesopotamia, Syria, and Palestine were destined to be detached from the Ottoman Empire with the inhabitants given the opportunity for self-determination, or the massacres perpetrated by the Turks against the Armenians, Greeks, and Assyrians during the First World War.

This was one of many memorials submitted by Indian Muslims supporting the Sultan during the allied peace negotiations with the Ottoman State.

RELATED

The recent tragicomic events at the church of the All-Holy Taxiarhes in the area of Megalo Revma of Constantinople, specifically, the assault by Archimandrite Chrysanthos on Metropolitan Athenagoras of Kydonion which involved the slapping of the archpriest's cheeks while he was venerating the icon of the Virgin Mary, are not only lamentable but also pitiful for the Patriarchate itself.

Top Stories

Columnists

A pregnant woman was driving in the HOV lane near Dallas.

General News

NEW YORK – Meropi Kyriacou, the new Principal of The Cathedral School in Manhattan, was honored as The National Herald’s Educator of the Year.

Video

9 Are Facing Charges in What Police in Canada Say is the Biggest Gold Theft in the Country’s History

TORONTO (AP) — Police said nine people are facing charges in what authorities are calling the biggest gold theft in Canadian history from Toronto’s Pearson International airport a year ago.

Allman Brothers Band co-founder and legendary guitarist Dickey Betts dies at 80 Dickey Betts, who died Thursday at age 80, really was born a ramblin’ man.

NEW YORK  — New York police removed a pro-Palestinian protest encampment at Columbia University on Thursday and arrested more than 100 demonstrators, including the daughter of a prominent Minnesota congresswoman.

ATHENS - The special 'Easter Basket,' which offers traditional Easter foods at lower or unchanged prices, will come into effect from April 24 to May 4.

LIVERPOOL - Liverpool failed to overcome a three-goal deficit and was eliminated from the Europa League on Thursday despite beating Atalanta 1-0 in the second leg of their quarterfinal matchup.

Enter your email address to subscribe

Provide your email address to subscribe. For e.g. [email protected]

You may unsubscribe at any time using the link in our newsletter.